20 November 2026

Tending Neglected Rural Places

I've spent most of my life in Kansas and Nebraska. Abandoned farms, abandoned towns, and declining small towns and villages are everywhere!


From Front Porch Republic

By Hadden Turner

Strip Mine Jesus warmed my localist heart.

The village of Shap in the English county of Cumbria is a place which has quite literally been passed by and left behind. Despite its current sleepy village appearance, the unmissable presence of its defunct steel works indicates that Shap used to be a much more vibrant and busy place. The A6 road, which for centuries was the main western route from England into Scotland, passes right through the middle of the village and brought a constant stream of traffic, tourists, and income into the coffers of Shap’s businesses and coaching inns.

The abundant flow of traffic and tourists has, however, long since ceased. The M6 motorway, built in the 1970s to take pressure off the somewhat treacherous A6, bypassed the village, bringing Shap’s economic heyday to an abrupt end.

Shap is far from the only rural place to have suffered from decline and neglect in our modern, urban-centric age. All across the western world, rural communities have fallen victim to what Wendell Berry has described as the “centripetal forces” exerted by urbanism, industrialism, and economic progress, which have sucked investment, capital, attention, and, most importantly, people, out of rural places and into urban environs.

The combined effects of these forces are stark. Ghost towns, flyover counties, and dilapidated communities are common across much of rural America. Here in the North of England where I live, former mining towns and fishing communities are desperately trying to keep hold of their young people, and across the rest of Britain, news breaks almost every day of another pub, village shop, or parish church that has closed its doors for the last time, leaving rural communities bereft of services and cherished cultural institutions.

Our world is becoming increasingly urban at the expense of the rural. What our rural places need are advocates. They also desperately need rooted residents committed to them for the long haul. Oil City, Pennsylvania, has found both a passionate advocate and a rooted resident in Charles Cotherman, author of Strip Mine Jesus: Hope for the Rural Church, Small Towns & Overlooked Places.

Cotherman knows what it is like to live in a left-behind place; he grew up next to an abandoned strip mine in rural Pennsylvania. He also knows what it is like to move away in search of opportunity, excitement, and prestige; he left his rural home to study at university and then again in search of intentional community in Philadelphia.

However, contrary to what most of us do in the rootless and transient age we live in, Cotherman and his wife chose to move back to their marginal rural community, Oil City, Pennsylvania, to plant a church and to pour their lives into blessing this overlooked and struggling place. This sacrificial move back to the rural gives Cotherman’s words authenticity; here is a man who not only means what he says but has lived in accordance with what he has “preached.” His book has thus earnt a hearing.

At its heart, Strip Mine Jesus is Cotherman’s plea for us to consider how each of us can be agents of renewal in the places we call home, especially if they happen to be rural or overlooked. It is worth remarking at this point that there are plenty of struggling, neglected inner city localities too. However, Cotherman’s focus is decidedly on the rural. Deprived and struggling inner city areas have already received much attention in the literature and media; it is time to put the rural in the spotlight for a change.

Cotherman’s plea, however, is a bold one. By making it, he forces his readers to ask ourselves two uncomfortable questions, questions that few dare to ask or even consider in our modern age: Could we root ourselves to our home places for the long haul, forsaking the siren calls of the “better,” easier, and more profitable, even if our place is undesirable, damaged, struggling, or just plain boring? Or, bolder still, could we intentionally move or return to an overlooked or struggling rural place and partner with those already present for its good and its renewal?

It is vital, though, that we establish the exact kind of rural places Cotherman is focusing his attention on in this book. This is especially important for British readers, who are likely to have a very different conception of the rural to Cotherman and his fellow Americans. When the average British person thinks of the rural, they instinctively think of thatched cottages, village greens, and beautiful countryside replete with hedgerows or drystone walls. This imagery constitutes the rural idyll, a firmly ingrained perception of the rural in the British consciousness. Testament to this is how the often the idyll was evoked during World War II to inspire the British troops as to what they were fighting to defend. The popularity of the hit TV show, All Creatures Great and Small, which is distinctly idyllic and nostalgic in its portrayal of rural life, shows just how much modern Brits are also enamoured with the idea of the rural idyll.

The construct of the rural as idyllic helps to explain the small but significant ”escape to the country” urban-to-rural migration which has become popular in Britain in recent years. On the one hand, this trend could be perceived as positive: rural places in Britain, even idyllic ones, are in need of more committed residents. However, many of these new rural residents harbor attitudes and motives wholly different to the “faithful presence” in rural places that Cotherman is calling readers to adopt. They have also moved to locations which are as far removed from neglected and overlooked as can be.

The motives, then, which are driving much of the rural-idyll migration occurring in Britain are comfort, escape, and picturesque beauty. Solitude and isolation rather than community are also often the goal. These new rural dwellers haven’t moved to be a blessing to their new places, nor to contribute to rural culture, customs, and traditions; they moved for their own pleasure and purposes. They moved to escape the hustle and bustle of the city and to establish their own idyll, not to enter into the complexities and challenges of rural life or work towards their renewal.

These are people who in the words of Allen Stanton wish to have the “virtue of rurality without the life of rurality.” In fact, many of these rural idyll migrants are servient to one of the three modern idols that Cotherman identifies which prevent people from being a faithful, rooted presence in rural places: the idol of autonomy.

Instead of rural escapism, Cotherman is advocating for costly commitment and sacrificial love directed to overlooked and struggling rural places, the kind of places people move away from and not towards. Embarking on such a move is hard, costly, and is potentially marked by much suffering. Cotherman does not deny this. In fact, he is explicit on this point, devoting an entire chapter to the topic of suffering in which he argues that “to commit oneself to a specific place and people for a long time, perhaps even for a lifetime means entering into layers of suffering that are hard to separate and impossible to avoid. The suffering that marks any place will eventually touch those who choose to stay.”

If we are to become men and women willing to embark on this costly endeavour of rooted rural living, we will need to nurture certain dispositions that counter the prevailing trends and attitudes that surround us. These attitudes include the celebrity mindset, an over-emphasis on efficiency, and a valorisation of autonomy (the three idols Cotherman identifies) along with comfort, ease, frictionlessness, and individualism.

Virtues and attitudes that may help cultivate an openness to the rural include patience, commitment, long-suffering, an interest in traditions, and an agrarian mindset. However, the keystone disposition Cotherman bases his whole ethic of renewal around is that of attention. It is a wise choice. “What we see—what we choose to focus our eyes and attention on—shapes the contour of our lives,” and not only our lives, but also “the people and places around us.” As Cotherman says, “to attend is to amend the world, to initiate a process of change with ripples that stretch beyond the borders of what we can foresee.”

If for Wendell Berry “it all turns on affection,” Cotherman’s book reminds us that attention must precede affection for affection not to be based on mere feelings and abstract or sentimental notions. Many say they love the rural, but what most mean by that is the “rural” of their imaginations and not what it is really like or that which they have come to know from personal and practical experience. It is a whole other matter to say one loves the rural after one has lived there and fixed attention on a particular, damaged place for a long time. Only then can one truly love the rural. And only after people have given attention to a place can they know how to be a blessing to it in accordance with its particularities and limitations.

Foregrounding attention is not without its shortcomings and dangers. First, attention can be used for selfish ends; think of the short-term attention of those that come to exploit a place for selfish gain. They may focus all their attention on getting to know a place, but only so that they can profit from it. Their attention is not directed to benevolent aims. If we are honest, sometimes our attention too is directed toward our places for similar exploitative or selfish purposes. Our attention and the motives behind it need to be subject to critique.

Second, attention can lead us to see too much. This is especially pertinent for those rooted to a place which is suffering from acute and/or chronic issues, such as social deprivation or intractable ecological degradation. Attention towards these places could easily lead to despair: what is seen and experienced is too much to handle. Further, the closer we look, the greater the depths of brokenness we discover and the more powerful and entrenched the forces of decline and degradation will appear. The danger is that we go on looking until we are overwhelmed. It takes a strong man or woman not to quit under such circumstances

Addressing this critical problem constitutes the genius of the book and is what sets it apart from others written on rural renewal and rootedness. Whereas other books do not have an answer to this problem apart from recourse to human willpower, Cotherman directs our eyes to the ultimate solution: God. We don’t need to rely on our own affection and commitment towards rural places, nor are we alone in our endeavours. We are living in a place that God already loves and where God is already at work. And He can help us to love wherever we are: “we don’t have to manufacture a first love for any place. All we have to do is look for how Christ’s love is already at work and join him in it right where we are.”

For all that is good and commendable about the book there is one apparent omission from Cotherman’s approach for rural renewal which threatens to undermine, or, at the very least, weaken what he is advocating for. There is surprisingly little focus throughout the book on what a community can do together under a shared vision for its place, a vision which has been forged out of dialogue and a politics of compromise (which Roger Scruton in How to Think Seriously about the Planet argues is essential for any positive action for the betterment of a place).

At points, Cotherman makes brief mention of the need for communal action, and certainly by foregrounding the role of the church in renewal Cotherman is making implicit mention of it. However, I would imagine the natural or most intuitive perspective from which this book will be read is the perspective of what we as individuals or families can do.

Hence this inattention constitutes a real lack. What communities need perhaps most of all if they are to remain healthy and vibrant is a shared love, vision, and work, some good that its members are collectively striving for or wishing to maintain. Examples abound, but they could include local heritage and unique traditions; a traditional industry the community is centred around; an agrarian economy; or a unique aesthetic the place is famous for, but which needs continual maintenance if it is to persist, such as the Fachwerk of many German rural villages.

The importance of a shared vision becomes clear when we consider that one of the chief reasons why intentional communities often fail is they have no shared vision they are striving for beyond that of merely cultivating “community” (whatever that is taken to mean). The problem with this is that everyone has their own desires for what community means, and these may be in irreconcilable conflict with each other. However, if a community has a vision for something tangible, a shared future they are striving for which takes into account members’ disparate needs and desires, and which has been forged by compromise and consensus, then a community has a strong chance of flourishing, even in the midst of hardship and neglect from the outside world.

Rather than focusing overly on what we as individuals can do, Strip Mine Jesus would have been strengthened by a more communal focus and by articulating what some of these shared visions could entail (beyond the vision of church evangelism and discipleship which Cotherman highlights or the rather abstract notion of renewal).

This issue aside, Strip Mine Jesus remains an excellent and much needed book. I found myself nodding in agreement through almost all of its pages. It warmed my localist heart. I hope it receives a wide readership and inspires a new generation of faithful people to commit to rural places and then seek, in the words of Francis Schaeffer, to bring about a “substantial healing” of them with God’s help. Cotherman has started the conversation as to why this substantial healing is required for our rural places. I hope a further book will be written to practically explore what this looks like and so show people how to live out this commitment in their own places and communities.

Last year, a little church started to meet in Shap’s Memorial Hall, a church full of farmers, drystone wallers, and their families hailing from Shap and the surrounding villages. It is the church I am delighted to call home. The presence of this little community of believers, who are seeking to be a blessing to the wider community, fills me hope for Shap, a hope that I share for each and every rural place that is home to a church full of believers who are giving their local place the loving care, attention, and action it needs the most, through their rooted “faithful presence.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are subject to deletion if they are not germane. I have no problem with a bit of colourful language, but blasphemy or depraved profanity will not be allowed. Attacks on the Catholic Faith will not be tolerated. Comments will be deleted that are republican (Yanks! Note the lower case 'r'!), attacks on the legitimacy of Pope Leo XIV as the Vicar of Christ, the legitimacy of the House of Windsor or of the claims of the Elder Line of the House of France, or attacks on the legitimacy of any of the currently ruling Houses of Europe.