Yes! Even though we fight "shadows, bureaucrats, and the mentally ill, all of whom occupy positions of power in 2026." We shall never surrender!
From The Imaginative Conservative
By Bradley J. Birzer, PhD
If we can keep the truth and the light alive—just as the medieval monasteries did for a 1,000 years—in our families, in our schools, and in or writings, we can maintain the West, even if just in embryo or memory, for ages to come.
This afternoon, a long-time friend brought to my attention a lament on the death of the West. I was not familiar with the author, Lars Moller, but he clearly has a sharp and fetching style. I must admit, I’m also not familiar with the website, The American Thinker, but it looks respectable, overall. So, I decided to take the essay as seriously as possible. After all, I’ve been teaching the history of Western Civilization and the Greats since the summer of 1995.
My very first thought was to be reminded to G.K. Chesterton’s incomparable epic, The Ballad of the White Horse. After King Alfred submitted to God’s grace—through the intercession of the Virgin Mary—he and his allies drive off the heathen Viking hordes. Still, there is a prophecy about what is coming in the twentieth century:
I know that weeds shall grow in it
Faster than men can burn;
And though they scatter now and go,
In some far century, sad and slow,
I have a vision, and I know
The heathen shall return.
They shall not come with war-ships,
They shall not waste with brands,
But books be all their eating,
And ink be on their hands.
Not with the humour of hunters,
Or savage skill in war,
But ordering all things with dead words,
Strings shall they make of beasts and birds,
And wheels of wind and star.
They shall come mild as a monkish clerk,
With many a scroll and pen;
And backward shall ye wonder and gaze,
Desiring one of Alfred’s days,
When pagans still were men.
It seems rather clear to me that Chesterton very much understood what was coming in the twentieth century—a century of murder, genocide, and bloodshed, a century of human denigration, modernity, and progressivism, a century of evil on the left and the right. Unlike King Alfred fighting the pagans—who were, at the very least, still men—we fight shadows, bureaucrats, and the mentally ill, all of whom occupy positions of power in 2026.
I am also reminded of Russell Kirk’s brilliance as expressed in his magisterial Roots of American Order of 1974: “Every age, suffering from violence and fraud, complains of its tribulations; but if we read history, we perceive that the human adventure is a chronicle of disasters. In every age, society has been relieved only by the endeavors of a few people moved by the grace of God.”
Let’s just imagine Kirk’s 1974. Things looked rather bleak. The economy was in the tank, we were in the midst of Watergate, and we had just lost the Vietnam War. Who, in his right mind, could possibly imagine the rise of a Ronald Reagan, a Margaret Thatcher, or a John Paul II? Yet, arise these three did, and they not only led us to greatness, they taught us, as Reagan so wonderfully put it, to be worthy of ourselves. Not only did each lead with integrity and grace, but each leavened and made us better than we really were. After all, who could forget 1989—an annus mirabilis—truly one of the finest years in world history.
Are things worse in 2026 than they were in 1974? They’re certainly bad right now, but I doubt that this is the exception rather than the norm.
But, let’s not just take 1974 and Reagan, Thatcher, and John Paul II.
Let’s imagine almost any of the greats of Western Civilization.
Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle all came at the end of classical Greece. Socrates and Plato experienced the Athenian polis at its height, but they also saw its destruction in 404BC, and Aristotle never witnessed it at all. Almost everything these three taught comes from a nostalgic memory of Athens, not a description as it actually was.
Or, let’s take Cicero. He came, critically, at the very end of the Roman republic. Indeed, we can say that with his execution in 43 BC, so fell the republic. The republic that Virgil, Tacitus, and Livy remembered was one of nostalgia for what was. It was not their Rome, but the Rome of their parents and grandparents.
Or, let’s take St. Augustine. Truly a nexus, he bridged not only the Roman world with the African world, but he also bridged the Ancient World with the Medieval World. By the time he wrote his City of God (AD 412-426), the Roman empire was in extreme crisis, as the barbarians had sacked Rome herself on August 24, 410, at midnight. Western Rome lasted only until 476. As such, St. Augustine wrote with critical nostalgia for what was.
St. Thomas Aquinas and Dante, too, came at the very end of the Middles Ages, with Dante, especially, thinking of a medieval Christendom on the edge of decay and finality.
Or, let’s imagine St. Thomas More. As my great friend, Stephen W. Smith has so persuasively argued, More, Erasmus, and St. John Fisher represented the best of the English renaissance, a second spring. Yet, because of the evil and machinations of Henry VIII, it all fell apart. More and Fisher, of course, were executed publicly, and the second spring withered.
So, is it really the end of the West? The West has died many, many times, and it’s revived many, many times. I can’t help but think about my role as a father, as a professor, and as a writer. As a father, my wife and I had seven children. Granted, we’re not exactly the demographic norm, but we certainly have raised our children in the hope that all will work out in the end, all according to God’s grace. As a professor, I teach at, arguably, the finest institution of higher learning in our current age. I walk into each class expecting to introduce my students to the greats and make of them citizens of the Cosmopolis and of the City of God. If I thought it was all over, why even get up in the morning. As a writer, I feel it’s my job to preserve all the greatness that has come before me—whether here at The Imaginative Conservative or in my books.
To be sure, tomorrow might not be bright. Indeed, it might be dreadful.
But, if we can keep the truth and the light alive—just as the medieval monasteries did for a 1,000 years—in our families, in our schools, and in or writings, we can maintain the West, even if just in embryo or memory, for ages to come. The rest is up to God.
_________
The featured image is “Crusader on Watch in the Mountains” (“Ein Kreuzritter auf der Wacht im Gebirge”), painted in 1836 by the German romantic painter Carl Friedrich Lessing.