Protestants Set a Faith Alone Trap... It Backfired Spectacularly Most Protestants quote Romans 4 to prove faith alone. But James 2 quotes the exact same verse about Abraham (Genesis 15:6) and arrives at the opposite conclusion - one of them has to be wrong, or we've misunderstood both. Paul quotes Genesis 15 to destroy boasting - Abraham didn't earn God's favour. James quotes Genesis 15 to destroy dead faith - Abraham's belief wasn't complete until it showed up in Genesis 22 when he obeyed. Same verse, two different enemies, two different meanings of "justify". 📌 The Point: Paul and James attack different errors - Paul rejects boasting and works of law; James rejects dead faith without transformation. Genesis 15 is the root, Genesis 22 is the fruit and fulfilment. 📖 Core Sources The Abraham Story: Genesis 15:6 - "Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness" Genesis 22:16-17 - "Because you have done this and have not withheld your son... I will indeed bless you" - notice the word "because"; blessing flows from obedient action Paul's Teaching (Romans 4): Romans 4:4-5 - Justification isn't wages earned by boasting or keeping the Mosaic law as a claim on God - Paul's target is placing God in our debt through our own natural power James's Teaching (James 2): James 2:21-24 - "Abraham was justified by works when he offered Isaac... faith was completed by works... a person is justified by works and not by faith alone" James 2:17 - Calls faith without works "dead faith" - asks whether such faith can save anyone; answer is no Catholic Teaching: CCC 1987-1995 - Justification is not merely external bookkeeping, but truly makes us righteous inwardly by grace Council of Trent, Session 6 (1547) - Initial justification is sheer grace received in faith; the justified must live faith through charity; works done in grace truly matter because grace renovates the person from within CCC 1988 - No one can merit initial justification; grace initiates everything CCC 1994 - Justification truly makes us righteous within, not just declared righteous on paper CCC 2006, 2011 - Merit isn't Pelagian self-salvation; it's grace-enabled cooperation; when God rewards our works, He crowns His own gifts Early Church: St. Augustine - "Faith working through love" (Galatians 5v6) is the faith that justifies; grace precedes all merit St. Clement of Rome (1st Letter to Corinthians, ch. 31-33) - Exhorts faith, grace, and a life of good works together 📺 Chapters 0:00 - The Problem: Romans 4 vs. James 2 on the Same Verse 2:17 - What the Bible Actually Says About Abraham (Genesis 15 & 22) 4:21 - How Catholic Teaching Resolves the Tension 6:00 - Objections: "Romans 4 Says Belief, Not Works," "You're Denying Grace," "This Destroys Assurance" 7:12 - Conclusion: Faith Alone Dies Alone; Faith Working Through Love Saves 🌐 Connect 📿 https://totuscatholica.org/rosary 🌍 https://totuscatholica.org/ ✉️ https://totuscatholica.org/contact 🔍 https://catholicexaminationofconscien... 💬 Question If Paul quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy boasting (Romans 4) and James quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy dead faith (James 2), how does that change your understanding of "faith alone"? Can both be true without contradicting each other?
05 February 2026
Abraham's 4000-Year-Old Test Exposes Protestant Theology
From Totus Catholica
Protestants Set a Faith Alone Trap... It Backfired Spectacularly Most Protestants quote Romans 4 to prove faith alone. But James 2 quotes the exact same verse about Abraham (Genesis 15:6) and arrives at the opposite conclusion - one of them has to be wrong, or we've misunderstood both. Paul quotes Genesis 15 to destroy boasting - Abraham didn't earn God's favour. James quotes Genesis 15 to destroy dead faith - Abraham's belief wasn't complete until it showed up in Genesis 22 when he obeyed. Same verse, two different enemies, two different meanings of "justify". 📌 The Point: Paul and James attack different errors - Paul rejects boasting and works of law; James rejects dead faith without transformation. Genesis 15 is the root, Genesis 22 is the fruit and fulfilment. 📖 Core Sources The Abraham Story: Genesis 15:6 - "Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness" Genesis 22:16-17 - "Because you have done this and have not withheld your son... I will indeed bless you" - notice the word "because"; blessing flows from obedient action Paul's Teaching (Romans 4): Romans 4:4-5 - Justification isn't wages earned by boasting or keeping the Mosaic law as a claim on God - Paul's target is placing God in our debt through our own natural power James's Teaching (James 2): James 2:21-24 - "Abraham was justified by works when he offered Isaac... faith was completed by works... a person is justified by works and not by faith alone" James 2:17 - Calls faith without works "dead faith" - asks whether such faith can save anyone; answer is no Catholic Teaching: CCC 1987-1995 - Justification is not merely external bookkeeping, but truly makes us righteous inwardly by grace Council of Trent, Session 6 (1547) - Initial justification is sheer grace received in faith; the justified must live faith through charity; works done in grace truly matter because grace renovates the person from within CCC 1988 - No one can merit initial justification; grace initiates everything CCC 1994 - Justification truly makes us righteous within, not just declared righteous on paper CCC 2006, 2011 - Merit isn't Pelagian self-salvation; it's grace-enabled cooperation; when God rewards our works, He crowns His own gifts Early Church: St. Augustine - "Faith working through love" (Galatians 5v6) is the faith that justifies; grace precedes all merit St. Clement of Rome (1st Letter to Corinthians, ch. 31-33) - Exhorts faith, grace, and a life of good works together 📺 Chapters 0:00 - The Problem: Romans 4 vs. James 2 on the Same Verse 2:17 - What the Bible Actually Says About Abraham (Genesis 15 & 22) 4:21 - How Catholic Teaching Resolves the Tension 6:00 - Objections: "Romans 4 Says Belief, Not Works," "You're Denying Grace," "This Destroys Assurance" 7:12 - Conclusion: Faith Alone Dies Alone; Faith Working Through Love Saves 🌐 Connect 📿 https://totuscatholica.org/rosary 🌍 https://totuscatholica.org/ ✉️ https://totuscatholica.org/contact 🔍 https://catholicexaminationofconscien... 💬 Question If Paul quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy boasting (Romans 4) and James quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy dead faith (James 2), how does that change your understanding of "faith alone"? Can both be true without contradicting each other?
Protestants Set a Faith Alone Trap... It Backfired Spectacularly Most Protestants quote Romans 4 to prove faith alone. But James 2 quotes the exact same verse about Abraham (Genesis 15:6) and arrives at the opposite conclusion - one of them has to be wrong, or we've misunderstood both. Paul quotes Genesis 15 to destroy boasting - Abraham didn't earn God's favour. James quotes Genesis 15 to destroy dead faith - Abraham's belief wasn't complete until it showed up in Genesis 22 when he obeyed. Same verse, two different enemies, two different meanings of "justify". 📌 The Point: Paul and James attack different errors - Paul rejects boasting and works of law; James rejects dead faith without transformation. Genesis 15 is the root, Genesis 22 is the fruit and fulfilment. 📖 Core Sources The Abraham Story: Genesis 15:6 - "Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness" Genesis 22:16-17 - "Because you have done this and have not withheld your son... I will indeed bless you" - notice the word "because"; blessing flows from obedient action Paul's Teaching (Romans 4): Romans 4:4-5 - Justification isn't wages earned by boasting or keeping the Mosaic law as a claim on God - Paul's target is placing God in our debt through our own natural power James's Teaching (James 2): James 2:21-24 - "Abraham was justified by works when he offered Isaac... faith was completed by works... a person is justified by works and not by faith alone" James 2:17 - Calls faith without works "dead faith" - asks whether such faith can save anyone; answer is no Catholic Teaching: CCC 1987-1995 - Justification is not merely external bookkeeping, but truly makes us righteous inwardly by grace Council of Trent, Session 6 (1547) - Initial justification is sheer grace received in faith; the justified must live faith through charity; works done in grace truly matter because grace renovates the person from within CCC 1988 - No one can merit initial justification; grace initiates everything CCC 1994 - Justification truly makes us righteous within, not just declared righteous on paper CCC 2006, 2011 - Merit isn't Pelagian self-salvation; it's grace-enabled cooperation; when God rewards our works, He crowns His own gifts Early Church: St. Augustine - "Faith working through love" (Galatians 5v6) is the faith that justifies; grace precedes all merit St. Clement of Rome (1st Letter to Corinthians, ch. 31-33) - Exhorts faith, grace, and a life of good works together 📺 Chapters 0:00 - The Problem: Romans 4 vs. James 2 on the Same Verse 2:17 - What the Bible Actually Says About Abraham (Genesis 15 & 22) 4:21 - How Catholic Teaching Resolves the Tension 6:00 - Objections: "Romans 4 Says Belief, Not Works," "You're Denying Grace," "This Destroys Assurance" 7:12 - Conclusion: Faith Alone Dies Alone; Faith Working Through Love Saves 🌐 Connect 📿 https://totuscatholica.org/rosary 🌍 https://totuscatholica.org/ ✉️ https://totuscatholica.org/contact 🔍 https://catholicexaminationofconscien... 💬 Question If Paul quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy boasting (Romans 4) and James quotes Genesis 15:6 to destroy dead faith (James 2), how does that change your understanding of "faith alone"? Can both be true without contradicting each other?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are subject to deletion if they are not germane. I have no problem with a bit of colourful language, but blasphemy or depraved profanity will not be allowed. Attacks on the Catholic Faith will not be tolerated. Comments will be deleted that are republican (Yanks! Note the lower case 'r'!), attacks on the legitimacy of Pope Leo XIV as the Vicar of Christ, the legitimacy of the House of Windsor or of the claims of the Elder Line of the House of France, or attacks on the legitimacy of any of the currently ruling Houses of Europe.