16 November 2026

An Open Letter to Pope Leo XIV on Synodality

His Holiness Pope Leo XIV

Palatium Apostolicum, 

Stradone dei Giardini

00120, Civitas Vaticana


Most Holy Father,


I would like to take this opportunity to write to you regarding synodality. I’m a convert to our Holy Faith from Anglicanism via Orthodoxy. Both of these churches are governed synodally, as you are undoubtedly aware, though the Anglican Communion does not use the term, calling their “synods” convocations or conventions. 


I watched as the Anglican Communion self-destructed because of its form of government. The average pew-sitter had little interest in going to meetings, so the “progressives” had a field day. Because of its form of government, the Anglican Communion has splintered, with the mainline Anglican Churches moribund and the “Continuing Anglican” Churches growing.


Later, not quite yet ready to become a Catholic, I joined the Serbian Orthodox Church. There, I was able to see firsthand the damage that synodal government had done. When I joined it, the Church was in schism in the US because of the lack of central authority, with a Bishop suing in civil court to retain his Diocese after having been replaced by the Holy Synod. It created such bad blood between the factions that a friend of mine drove me to my Pastor’s house, but refused to come in. Why? Because his parents, who belonged to the "other" side, lived next door and they would disown him if they saw him going into my Pastor's house.


The final straw came just weeks before my reception into the Catholic Church. I had become friends with the Catholic Chaplain at the local university. One night, at a party, he asked me what the ultimate authority in the Orthodox Church is. The answer, of course, is simple: an Ecumenical Council. However, the authority to call such a Council is undefined. The classic answer is “the Emperor”, since all seven Councils accepted by the Orthodox were convened by the Emperor. But, even the most fanatical “Moscow is the Third Rome” Orthodox cannot deny that, since 1918, there has been no Orthodox Emperor to call a Council.

As I thought about Father’s question, I came to realise that the Orthodox are a rudderless group of ethnic Churches without any central authority. This was proven by the 'Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church', a futile attempt in 2016 to finally hold the Pan-Orthodox Synod that they had been trying to organise for almost a century. Despite all the hope and hype, it was boycotted by one of the Ancient Patriarchates (Antioch), the largest autocephalous Church (Russia), the Church of Georgia, which, after it had been held, referred to it as the 'Council of Crete', rejecting the claim that the council was Pan-Orthodox and the idea that its texts reflected Orthodox Teaching and the Church of Bulgaria. The Orthodox Church in America was not invited, again because of the ethnic rivalries and lack of a central authority. 

And, if you need further proof, again, because of the lack of central authority, the Ecumenical Patriarch, the 'First Among Equals' of Orthodox Hierarchs and the Patriarch of Moscow, head of the largest Orthodox Church, were out of Communion with each other in 1996 and are again from 2018 until the present. 'One fold, One Shepherd'?

If the vision of “synodality” that your predecessor seems to have held becomes a reality, I foresee the same thing happening to my beloved Catholic Church that happened to the Anglicans and the Orthodox. I do not want to see the Church splintering, with the Americans going one way, the Germans another, and every Bishop’s Conference deciding doctrine and morality on its own.

A great comment I saw recently on a blog I read: “If Our Lord had followed ‘the synodal way’ and listened to his local committee, he would never have allowed himself to be crucified. Then where would we have been?”

I beg of you, Holiness, put a stop to the madness of “synodality”!

Kissing the Sacred Foot, I remain, Your Holiness' most obedient Child,


Jovan Weismiller


No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are subject to deletion if they are not germane. I have no problem with a bit of colourful language, but blasphemy or depraved profanity will not be allowed. Attacks on the Catholic Faith will not be tolerated. Comments will be deleted that are republican (Yanks! Note the lower case 'r'!), attacks on the legitimacy of Pope Leo XIV as the Vicar of Christ, the legitimacy of the House of Windsor or of the claims of the Elder Line of the House of France, or attacks on the legitimacy of any of the currently ruling Houses of Europe.