The Only Reply You Need to these Muslim Arguments

From Brian Holdsworth

Can God die? Muslims often argue that the Trinity and the Incarnation are incoherent, but their own theology makes that argument impossible. Islam’s dominant Divine Command Theory teaches that God can will anything whatsoever, even what seems incoherent or contradictory. Therefore Muslims cannot logically argue that the Trinity or the Incarnation are impossible, because their own theology denies any intrinsic limits on God’s power. At most they can claim that God wouldn’t do these things, which shifts the burden of proof and collapses their usual objections. ⏱️ Timestamps 00:00 – Why Muslim apologists target Christmas 01:05 – The viral “God can’t die” trap 02:06 – Chalcedon: Christians solved this centuries before Islam 02:41 – The only counter argument you need 03:41 – Divine Command Theory vs. Christian metaphysics 04:32 – The Euthyphro dilemma 06:57 – Why Muslims cannot say “God can’t…” 07:57 – Flipping the argument back on Islamic theology 09:33 – How Christianity actually answers the question 11:52 – Hypostatic union: one Person, two natures 13:24 – Why no one would invent Christianity