Four hundred years ago today, Pope Urban VIII consecrated the "new" St Peter's, replacing the old Church, commissioned by St Constantine the Great, Equal to the Apostles, Enlightener of the Roman Empire.
From One Peter Five
By Massimo Scapin
Uniting millions of faithful across the world.
Four hundred years ago, Pope Urban VIII (†1644) consecrated the new Vatican Basilica, restoring to the great temple of Peter its primary purpose: liturgical worship. As the diarist Giacinto Gigli (†1671) recorded:
On the 18th day of November 1626, which is each year a solemn day for the Dedication made by Pope St. Sylvester of the basilicas of St. Peter and St. Paul the Apostles […], Pope Urban VIII consecrated the New Basilica of Saint Peter in the Vatican […]. And on the previous day […] he ordered in Rome a vigil with fasting, and after the meal a solemn procession of all the clergy and regular religious from the church of St. Mark to St. Peter.[1]
The ceremony, celebrated 1,300 years after the first basilica was dedicated by Pope Sylvester I (†335) under Emperor Constantine (†337), crowned an unprecedented architectural and spiritual project. From the laying of the first stone on 18 April 1506 at the behest of Julius II (†1513), one hundred and twenty years of continuous work had passed. Absolute geniuses of Italian art contributed—Donato Bramante (†1514), Michelangelo Buonarroti (†1564), Carlo Maderno (†1629), and Gian Lorenzo Bernini (†1680)—alongside countless stonemasons, gilders, goldsmiths, and laborers whose names remain unknown. The meticulous registers of the Fabbrica di San Pietro, the organization created to oversee construction and still responsible for the basilica’s upkeep, document every nail, rope, and plank: a testament to a collective effort spanning generations.
Music played an equally central role. Paolo Agostini (†1629), director of music at St. Peter’s from 16 February 1626, organized the solemn celebration of 18 November, which now marked the consecration of the basilica itself, rather than the memory of its Constantinian predecessor. The Diary of the Papal Musical Chapel[2] notes that the rite was sung in Gregorian chant, with polyphonic motets reserved for the papal Mass that preceded the ceremony. Even without elaborate polyphony, the consecration lasted over four hours. A tapestry by Fabio Cristofani (†1689), part of a series devoted to the life of Urban VIII, depicts the pope carving the Greek and Latin alphabets with his crozier into a cross traced in ashes on the church floor. At second vespers, the Cappella Giulia, the Vatican Basilica’s choir, performed music for two or three choirs with reduced forces.
Agostini had the honor of directing the entire celebration in the pope’s presence. To achieve unprecedented acoustic effects, he positioned musicians and singers in the gallery encircling the dome, approximately fifty meters above the floor—a daring choice later imitated by many. The voices, particularly those of the famous castrati, seemed to descend from heaven, creating ethereal resonances and echoes. Urban VIII, enchanted by these soundscapes, encouraged this “spatial distribution” of choirs to heighten the liturgy’s sense of mystery and express the triumphant joy of the Tridentine Church. These festive innovations also inspired symbolic gestures: on the feast of the Prince of the Apostles, 29 June, Agostini organized twelve choirs—each led by the best masters of Rome’s churches—to recall Christ’s twelve disciples, employing renowned organists such as Pietro Heredia (†1648), Girolamo Frescobaldi (†1643), and Orazio Benevoli (†1672). These innovations quickly became a model for sacred music throughout Italy.
The musician Antimo Liberati (†1692), a papal singer from 1662, praised Agostini in 1685:
One of the most spirited and lively minds that music has had in our times in every kind of harmonic composition, of counterpoint, and of canon; and among his other marvelous works, he made heard in the basilica of St. Peter, when he was chapel master there, various modulations for four, six, and eight real choirs, and some that could be sung by four or six real choirs without diminishing or weakening the harmony, to the astonishment of all Rome. And if he had not died in the flower of manhood, he would have amazed the world even more, and if it were permitted, one could rightly say of him, ‘Consummatus in brevi explevit tempora multa’ [Wisdom 4:13: Having become perfect in a short while, he reached the fullness of a long career].[3]
Anyone who crosses the basilica’s threshold understands the words the French writer Charles Dupaty (†1788) recorded during his 1785 journey to Italy:
If I have not yet spoken to you of the church of St. Peter, it is because of the impossibility of finding, in any language, expressions suitable to describe it adequately […]. Here it is impossible to feel mediocre emotions or to have coarse thoughts.[4]
Four centuries later, the wonder remains undiminished: the majestic Michelangelesque dome, Bernini’s sweeping colonnade, and the golden light filtering through the windows continue to testify to a faith capable of inspiring the highest art.
Today, the Fabbrica di San Pietro, originally founded to build the “new Vatican temple,” ensures its daily preservation. The basilica remains not only a masterpiece of architecture and art but also the beating heart of the Catholic Church—a place of pilgrimage, liturgy, and prayer uniting millions of faithful across the world.
This anniversary invites reflection not only on the bold artistic enterprise but also on the spiritual and musical flourishing that made 18 November 1626 a pivotal moment in the history of Christianity and European culture.
A video documentary from EWTN: 400 Years of St. Peter's Basilica: Michelangelo, Bernini and the Tomb of St. Peter | EWTN Vatican[1] G. Gigli, Diario romano, 1608-1670, Rome 1958, p. 96; our translation.
[2] Cappella Sistina, Diario 45, f. 37v
[3] Cited in G. Baini, Memorie storico-critiche della vita e delle opere di Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina, Rome 1828, p. 42; our translation.
[4] C. Dupaty, Lettres sur l’Italie en 1785, Vol. 2, Paris 1788, p. 133 and 136; our translation.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments are subject to deletion if they are not germane. I have no problem with a bit of colourful language, but blasphemy or depraved profanity will not be allowed. Attacks on the Catholic Faith will not be tolerated. Comments will be deleted that are republican (Yanks! Note the lower case 'r'!), attacks on the legitimacy of Pope Leo XIV as the Vicar of Christ, the legitimacy of the House of Windsor or of the claims of the Elder Line of the House of France, or attacks on the legitimacy of any of the currently ruling Houses of Europe.